350 miles versus 39 fishermen; a tale of two fishes

by | Oct 16, 2019 | American Saltwater Guides Association, Fishing Clubs, Striped Bass Fishing

Share This Article On…

Max Appleman shook my hand pretty hard. We hadn’t met previously but both recalled a Fish Wrap piece from last year in which readers were encouraged to contact him regarding a potential change in striper regulations. A similar Fish Wrap piece with his contact information was picked up by The Pew Charitable Trust and widely distributed. His phone rang steadily for three days. Fishermen understood the severity of what his agency, the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission, was considering and they offered comments. It was pretty clear he was overwhelmed with responses.  

asfmchearing2Max was at URI this week for a public hearing regarding Addendum VI and its impending changes to striped bass regulations. The ramifications of the proposals are significant. They will affect Maryland to Maine. They may raise the minimum size of a keeper bass to 35”. They may introduce a slot limit. They may mandate circle hooks.

39 people made the time to attend.

There were more people at the local McDonalds. 

Fishing mortality rate is what the Addendum is designed to correct because the striper stock has experienced low recruitment over the last decade. 2012, 2014 and 2016 were pretty strong years but they weren’t enough. In 2017, we removed 7.1 million from the stock. In 2018, 5.8 million fish were removed including discards which die. “About 90% of total removals is attributed to the recreational sectors in the last few years,” Max said.

Approximately nine out of ten stripers landed recreationally are released and 9% of them are assumed to die after release.

asfmc hearing1

Then Max spoke of how we “interact” with striped bass. That’s a fine assessment of how we see that fishery and how much it means to us. It’s not just fishing, it’s interacting. So why weren’t more fishermen there?

Peter Jenkins, Chair of the American Saltwater Guides Association advocated for the 35” minimum size because his group thought it was most important to protect the females now. They’re worried long term conservation efforts may not be realized. The Association wants us to not ignore history and protect the largest breeders so he also called for the one fish at 18” for the Chesapeake since that’s where the vast majority of stripers spawn. 

There was a wide variety of people in the room, including charter boat captains, recreational fishermen and fishing clubs. With the exception of one charter boat captain who raised valid concerns about inexperienced anglers being forced to use circle hooks, no one from the commercial fishing industry spoke. 

Max Appleman helps explain the regulatory process

Hooks can generate almost as much discussion as any other regulation changes. Many fishermen and women will tell you mandating a particular hook can and will mean the difference between catching and losing. They’re great for some types of chunk bait but they’re lousy for soft sections, like the middle of a menhaden. There was talk of treble hooks. They’re pretty destructive to fish and while not on the official document, it’s something to think about when we spend winter nights hugging a glass of something brown and swapping out old mono and rusty hooks. Properly rigged single hooks can be just as effective with less damage to the fish and therefore, less mortality. 

“We believe that circle hooks are important when bait fishing, but mandating use would be unenforceable,” said Steve Mederios of the R.I. Saltwater Anglers Association, supporting Option C under 3.2. They also support Sub Option 2-A3: one fish at a 32″ – 40″ slot limit and for the Chesapeake Bay fisheries, Sub Option 2-B1: one fish at an 18″ minimum.  

Greg Vespe of the Aquidneck Island Striper Team agreed with RISAA then asked for future discussions about a trophy tag and more enforcement. Mike Laptew spoke of his history with fish and the need more law enforcement. “…The year class we all hung our hats on,” said he said, referencing Virginia’s over-harvest that largely imploded an entire year’s worth of fishing. That kind of language just shows how much we value stripers. It was good to hear many voices supporting law enforcement, except it wasn’t on the agenda and those comments need to go directly to our legislators.

Last year you rang Max Appleman’s phone off the hook; how about making some local calls and get real support behind RIDEM Law Enforcement. 

We don’t want a moratorium. We want to go fishing and catch striped bass but Archie Bunkering some commentary at a screen doesn’t make change.

Image result for archie bunker

Standing up at a microphone and speaking your mind does. Fisheries regulators are mandated to read and consider all public comments before they draft changes. That’s the beauty of our system; it’s hinged on our voices but the system fails if we don’t speak.

Earlier in the day, a man from Albany, New York purchased a beautiful Abel pocket knife from The Sporting Shoppe in Richmond.

ABL00089_Native Rainbow.01 - Edited

Abel/Spyderco knife

It was a gift.

He drove 350 miles to purchase a knife because it bore the pattern of a brown trout, a fish he loves to catch on the fly. He drove six hours to buy a knife that looks like a fish.

With almost 47,000 saltwater license holders in this state, 39 people drove to Narragansett to speak about striped bass, which are overfished and overfishing is occurring, to the people who regulate them.  As public meetings and comment periods occur for other fish populations, I hope you all email my new friend Max at mappelman@asmfc.org. Public comments are the hinges that swing big doors. 



Fall Is Trophy Time
Chef Lucia’s Fall Feast
Cloudy skies over cloudy water
Cloudy skies over cloudy water
Don’t Miss RI ‘Tog Classic



The Sporting Shoppe at The Preserve is proud to sponsor The Preserve Fishing & Outdoor Report by Todd Corayer. The report is broadcast on WPRO 99.7 FM & 630 AM. Click to watch now.

About The Author

Todd Corayer is a lifelong fisherman and occasional hunter whose writing relies on poor penmanship, sarcasm and other people’s honest fish stories while seeing words as puzzle pieces that occasionally all fit together perfectly.

His work has appeared in The Double Gun Journal, On The Water MagazineThe Fisherman, The Bay Magazine,  So Rhode IslandSporting ClassicsCoastal AnglerNY Lifestyles, The Island Crier, and very often in the wonderful RISAA Newsletter.

You Might Also Enjoy…

a little hand in hand at a bass tourney

This year we have been blessed with so many bluebird mornings and sunny days with fish of many species all around us. It’s only natural that being the Ocean State, surely most of our focus is on fishing the ocean. There are charter boats to hire, trips around Block...

Up from the ashes, Big Bear is a local sportsman hot spot

Fire can destroy everything as it tears through roofs, walls and hearts. What fire doesn’t always do is destroy the human spirit and the shared passions to rebuild. When Big Bear Hunting and Firearms in Harmony burned in January of 2018, the building was left in tough...

a few fluke, bragging rights and the contest season

  This past weekend blessed us with fair winds, calm seas and just enough fog on Sunday to add a cloak of secrecy to those drifting for fluke which so far, has been slow but decent. Most success has been found along that magical 50-60’ line just south of Charlestown...

It was raining fish on opening day and Peter Jenkins is building fish abundance

Spring’s greatest day, the opening of trout season in Rhode Island was a soggy success. Steady rains came early and often, winds pushed everyone around and skies were zebra striped with sheets of clouds racing south to north. Two days later, under far more obliging...

“A season’s first trout with a hundred pigeons to fight poaching”

Amazing. Everybody waits. Ladies and gentlemen, crouched forward on cold seats, crowded into low sided skiffs, pacing around barely green shorelines. Everybody waits. A few without their glasses look to those young enough to read a watch in the dusky light of early...

Consider sharing this article with your fishing buddies!

We appreciate you sharing the Fish Wrap with your fishing community.