How to not keep a fish secret & learn from local fishermen

by | May 25, 2017 | Block Island, Striped Bass Fishing

Share This Article On…

This edition of Fish Wrap originally appeared in the Southern RI Newspapers family of, well, newspapers.

Steam over to the east side of Prudence Island, cast a live pogie, catch a striper. Head up to the Taunton River or the Tiverton Basin, cast a hunk of squid, catch a striper. Get in your kayak, paddle a salt pond or breachway, throw a DOA jig or an X-Rap, catch a striper. Work your way around the top of the Providence River, catch a striper. It’s not always that easy but this might be the best Spring fishing in years and the best tip to find those fish might come from a fishing column, we hope, a tackle shop or the internet.

Fishermen need access to shorelines and to information but there’s arguments that go with each.

Unlike the selfish plattors over in Westerly’s unPleasant View, whose view is more pleasant without anyone in it, and are hell bent to keep us away from “their beach”, this week we’re interested in better people sharing access to fishing spots, fish caught and fish returned.


Mr. Fish, Dave Henault


David Henault at Ocean State Tackle has taken some heat for sharing fish reports on his social media sites. Chris McGuire, Marine Program Director for The Nature Conservancy, is helping commercial fishing boats report more accurate landing and discard numbers. Both have an agenda of communication and improvement to the different fisheries. Both are worth your time to listen to their words and advice.

Dave posts regularly about who’s catching what where, often with information about best bait or lures. He runs a busy tackle store, he sells bait, he fishes like a fiend, he lives a big life. Thousands of people follow him on different platforms because he’s a wealth of information, not to mention a total character. Surely some have time to cruise the bays, beaches and bottoms to find fish feeding but many more rely on reports for a head start.

Part of the argument is that as soon as someone out on a hot spot or someone like Henault or Captain Dave Monti, who writes excellent reports covering recreational and commercial fishing as well as state and federal regulations, posts a report, it’s the end of the world for that spot. Center consoles will race from points unknown to catch every fish, kayaks will slink in under cover of darkness to take the biggest shallow water stripers, every last fish will be removed or scared back to the canyons. And don’t even think of posting reports about tuna fishing as apparently that’s way off limits, according to some short-tempered seasonal anglers.


cameras in the rigging show work and fish on deck


Chris and The Conservancy has facilitated funding to install cameras on 14 commercial boats for capturing images and data.


Sen. Whitehouse & The Nature Conservancy’s Chris McGuire in the port of Galilee

From the culling board video, observers on land can determine species and size, which eventually will help make fisheries policy more accurate and timely. Chris Brown, captain of the Galilee based F/V Proud Mary, offered his boat to test the technology.

“Fishing is not a right, it’s a privilege,” he said, adding “I want to be part of the solution.”


Captain Chris Brown

There’s a parallel with The Conservancy’s work, the unPleasant View folks and those angry about live-time reports. Read through any fishing magazine, notice how often references are made to “our fish”, “our beaches” or “commercial guys are catching all our insert-fish-here.”

We have a possession issue when it comes to resources and access; I say it’s not “our ocean”, it’s “the ocean”.

Not everyone is happy about cameras on boats. Having spent a few years out there, my initial thought was commercial boats are hallmarks of independence, run and worked by fishermen who don’t typically want or enjoy public scrutiny. One fisherman I met thought this pilot project opens the door to mandatory cameras on all boats, and worse, that fishermen will be required to pay for them. Chris McGuire does see this as the probable path, saying, “We’re going down that track,” but technology breeds efficiency which ultimately lowers costs.


Nothing is what it used to be: commercial fishing is more complex than ever, cameras are cheaper than human on-board observers, online reports are instant. The main goal is to preserve and protect our, sorry, the fisheries as we better understand how they are intertwined and interdependent.

IMG_0621 - Edited

Sen. Whitehouse poses for picture in front of the FV Proud Mary

My logical argument is that most reports aren’t all that revealing. We’re New Englanders, we know East is the least, a Southeast wind blows itself out after 12 hours, we know bluefish are near by the smell of watermelon in the air. The Connecticut guy with the dented aluminum camper, with more rod holders that ten men might ever need, with the spotless cooler bolted to the front bumper, well that guy might benefit from knowing there are schoolies inside of the Charlestown Breachway and a few keepers out on the end where the weird rotation happens and the whole joint smells like Camel straights. The rest of us should know that when there’s thirty, five-gallon buckets lining the Great Island bridge, when shad trees bloom on Block Island (and for Lord’s sake can people stop calling it “Block”?), when Dave Monti tells you pogies are all over the upper Bay, when you look through the windshield wipers and realize it’s May, when you start seeing orange life jackets flying out of Whalers being trailered for the first time, the bass are here.

It’s not a spot burn to say that stripers feed on the east side of Prudence, it’s common sense.

While some hemorrhage money to keep you out, The Nature Conservancy is paying to better understand what fishermen bring in, what goes overboard and what species are migrating at certain times. That’s information that helps all of us on all sorts of levels. Dave Henault reports what he sees, which helps us catch fish. With a new and welcome focus on Catch/Grin/Release®, it’s not going to matter who fishes where because with accurate data, accurate reports and responsible fishermen focused on the fisheries, abundance will only build.

That’s a report I’ll write every week.


  1. Susan Costa

    Nice article Todd. M-I-L >

  2. Tom Houde

    Nice read!

  3. Deb Thompson

    Well written alternative perspective…. Excellent, informative, serious, humorous read—-Really enjoyed!




The Sporting Shoppe at The Preserve is proud to sponsor The Preserve Fishing & Outdoor Report by Todd Corayer. The report is broadcast on WPRO 99.7 FM & 630 AM. Click to watch now.

About The Author

Todd Corayer is a lifelong fisherman and occasional hunter whose writing relies on poor penmanship, sarcasm and other people’s honest fish stories while seeing words as puzzle pieces that occasionally all fit together perfectly.

His work has appeared in The Double Gun Journal, On The Water MagazineThe Fisherman, The Bay Magazine,  So Rhode IslandSporting ClassicsCoastal AnglerNY Lifestyles, The Island Crier, and very often in the wonderful RISAA Newsletter.

You Might Also Enjoy…

How To Go Nowhere at the D.M.V.

Trailer Trash Spoiler Alert: Nothing Happened at the DMV. This is the second installment of one man's journey to register a small boat trailer. The first piece, which is pretty important to the big picture of the problem, can be read here. A sandwich walks into a bar....

did someone say whippoorwill?-narragansett times, 4/25/2014

Spring came home and kicked winter out but apparently never locked the door. Cold rain and sleet have kept our water temperatures low, postponed the arrival of our precious striped bass and given lots of us a good case of the shrugs.  Largemouth’s are being landed,...

good ice, great fishing and giving into parenting

 A freezing cold November day is nature’s way of reminding us ice fishing season is almost here. It’s time to get out the buckets, tip ups, hand warmers, augers and camo coolie cups. Ice fishing in South County is a peaceful experience, one that gets us out of the...

howard reed has had enough and that’s a damned shame

A new Penn Spinfisher V spinning reel lists for about $180 at a tackle store but Amazon will send you one for $130, no tax, free shipping. You’d be a fool to pass up that offer, right? “Are you going to get Amazon to spool that for you?” asked Howard Reed at Galilee...

toxic algae closes shellfishing & an albie keeps a flyrod

This week: how to avoid toxic shellfish, where to catch a striper and how to lose a fly rod and smile about it. Narragansett Bay has been closed for the first time due to a bloom of the toxic phytoplankton Pseudo-nitzschia. From the mouth of Narragansett Bay to...

Consider sharing this article with your fishing buddies!

We appreciate you sharing the Fish Wrap with your fishing community.